(Suggestions for what follows "in which" in the title are welcome.)
RKJ replied to my previous post,
So Julie, I'm not sure you've given us much insight into the comparison between lepers and gay people. It seems many people are interested in taking a stand against hypocrisy in the church (or bigotry or stupidity) and who would like to be for any of those things? But how are gay people like lepers? Jesus was not afraid to touch lepers but he didn't leave them as lepers either. I understand your petition rebellion. Now what about the people. To call a gay person a leper is to invoke imagery of decay and disease which cannot be left alone if one is truly compassionate. Where does your analogy end?
No, I sure haven't given any insight into the comparison, and my word choice is potentially even misleading. At best it is a very loose analogy, because it means more to me, because of what I associate, than to the reader. This post is better thought out but at times I am frustrated, sarcastic, angry, impassioned, and very personal. I normally seek to be thoughtful and balanced. I don't want to make a pretty little neat argument in this post. I am tired of the status quo. Let's talk about turning over tables.
Most of this is "I don't know but there is something far more important." There's no stunning theological argument to be had here. There's just an argument about priority. I'd like to tell you, hey, this is just how I see things for myself and you're welcome to differ... but I'd be lying to try and avoid conflict. I'm convinced that this argument about priority is absolutely right for every single human being.
The argument is this:
love comes first. I don't mean sissy love from afar without getting our hands dirty. I mean gritty, real, messy, beautiful, difficult love. (I could more easily show you than tell you, but this is a blog; please forgive my words for falling short.) Doing what Christ did in coming to earth. Sitting down and caring for people with no agenda whatsoever. To be one of those people whose qualities I mentioned in
an earlier post:... approachable, accepting, slow to anger, slow to judge, quick to pardon, seeking to understand, seeking to love, seeking to do right. They create a space where the tide of fear is held back, where no secret is too dark, no failure too deep, where any uncertainty is permitted. Where our humanity can be laid bare without shame or judgement.
In light of that, on to my comment about making lepers out of gays.
Before I start generalizing about "the church", I ought to tell the reader my background, because this is far from a balanced view, and there are plenty of churches and church people (hopefully) who differ from my primary experience. My family's Catholic and believes "you shouldn't show support for the gay lifestyle" such as by socializing with a gay couple (although just half the couple is okay, I guess). My friends in college were mostly Pentecostal and believed that homosexuality was something you needed healing or to be set free from. I also attended a 'nondenominational' Christian church that was nonetheless to the fundamentalist side a la Moody Bible Institute. These are my influences and views of the "Christian" "church;" again, I am aware that many individuals differ from the official views with which people have attempted to indoctrinate me. And so when I refer to "the church", it is some aggregate of these official groups, and much more about negative characteristics than positive ones.
What I was trying to express is that the church, by standing against gay marriage, is making gays unwelcome, casting them out. In a some ways, treating them the way 'good' people treated lepers, labelling them as unclean and somehow less than human. I don't like the spirit of the thing.
How does that model the love of Christ?Well gee, what an effective way to drive people away from Christ! It's pretty darn easy to see condemnation written all over stuff like that to see "Christians" and thus God as hateful and condemning, not just of actions but of people.
I'm not saying either of those are or are not the intended message of any person or of any church body, I'm saying that it's easy enough to receive that message from those actions. How does that model the love of Christ?RKJ wrote,
"To call a gay person a leper is to invoke imagery of decay and disease which cannot be left alone if one is truly compassionate." That's another place where the analogy fits, to a point... so even while "the church" produces the clean-unclean relationship, individual Christians who "have it right" try to produce the Christ-leper relationship that RKJ has so nicely summarized. The difference here is that the leper knows he is sick... does the homosexual? And is there really anything wrong with him? And what are the effects of trying to help somebody that doesn't think they need help? And what if there really isn't anything wrong, and it's the splinter versus the log? Riddle me that!
How does that model the love of Christ?Is there any argument being made today about homosexuality, to justify condemning people or behavior, to which we couldn't respond "the Pharisees said that about..." Does that scare anybody besides me?
How does that model the love of Christ?To my family, I say, how would your friend and his partner feel when you refuse to go out to dinner together? Are they really going to believe it's just on principle? (Oh, it's just a misunderstanding? Well then who is going to take responsibility for making real communication occur?)
How does that model the love of Christ?Of course the question is bound to come up, what do I think? I'm talking about it here on my blog and saying why gay marriage should not be outlawed, because it drives people from Christ, (I could also make an argument for discrimination), but that doesn't address the morality of homosexuality. These are two different conversations that most people do not separate or think should be separate.
If somebody asks me if I believe homosexuality is wrong, then I'll say I don't feel qualified to make a judgement on that. Because I don't, I'm not convinced that I know God's
heart in the matter. If you press me? I'll say f*** it, if you will think I love you any less or any different because you think I have the audacity to think you are "living in sin" then no, it's not wrong. If anything at all stops me from loving extravagantly, than f*** it, that's gotta go.
That is the pearl of great price.
That is what it means to be willing to forsake everything to follow Christ.